Casa Mia

$$
Open
yelp logo

(174)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

505 N Meridian
Puyallup, WA 98371
+1 (253) 770-0400
http://www.casamiarestaurants.com
In 1952, the first Casa Mia Restaurant was opened in a storefront space in Hoquiam, Washington by Phil Bellofatto, and Italian-American that grew up in an apartment above one of the original Italian Restaurants and Pizzerias in New York. Pizza was virtually unknown. Casa Mia, one of the first Italian restaurants in Washington State is credited with changing all that. To this day, the menu at Casa Mia is centered on Phils recipes, with nearly everything still made the old fashioned way. Pizza is hand tossed, with fresh dough made daily at each of our restaurants, then baked on a brick hearth. Our tomato sauce is made daily in each restaurant, simmered for six hours to develop its rich and distinctive flavors. Please come in today and try our ward winning Pizza's.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.0174 reviews
Photo of Nick H.
Nick H.
9/6/2025

We go for the pizzas! No one makes anything like the Chicken Strada that we have found. If my wife and I want a delicious pizza that is different from anything else - this is what we get. It IS...

Read more on Yelp
Mark S.
1/2/2026

Cozy atmosphere, is where it ends. I had all u can eat spaghetti it tasted like canned sauce with too much water. The worst part was I ordered a dbl. whisky sour they used crown yuck instead of...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Kay C.
Kay C.
11/26/2025

The food was not good, I got the tortellini an it was like soup with noodles. American portion so to much where you're full. I was told the pizza is good but I'm sorry don't really want to try....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Aimee G.
Aimee G.
11/9/2025

First time and will NOT return. Ordered Margherita pizza and it was definitely not a Margherita pizza! Tons of cheese with shredded basil on top. The cheese tasted cheap. Also ordered chicken parm...

Read more on Yelp
Jon G.
11/9/2025

After decades of patronage I won't be back. I was served the worst plate of spaghetti I've ever had. I only had two bites. I wasn't going to say anything but when the waiter asked if there was...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Round Table Pizza
Eating places, Pizza restaurants, Pizzeria, chain

Round Table Pizza

101
•
$
"Good pizza, friendly staff. Prices are creeping up but you get a salad with your order which is better than most pizza places"
photo of Eric H.
Spud's Pizza Parlor
Eating places, Bars and lounges, Bar (drinking places)

Spud's Pizza Parlor

212
•
$
"This place has changed owners and workers multiples times. We've been in an out of here my ENTIRE LIFE. My dad and his best friends grew up going here from HS so it has a lot of memories. We went..."
photo of Mary W.
Round Table Pizza
Eating places, Pizza restaurants, Italian restaurant

Round Table Pizza

104
•
$
"Great pizza , not ur pizza hut usual pizza knot King art is not bad if u like olive etc Chicken wings i dont like But pizza is triple aaa yes Will go again of course Weekdays 5 to 7.not bad"
photo of Ben N.
United States›Washington›Puyallup›Casa Mia

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement