New Brother's Pizza

$$
Open
yelp logo

(46)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

2006 Jefferson Hwy
Fishersville, VA 22939
+1 (540) 949-8900
http://www.newbrotherspizza.com

New Brother's Pizza, located in Fishersville, VA, has been a beloved fixture in the Waynesboro and Fishersville communities for 16 years, specializing in pizza, pasta, and subs. Known for baking over 30,000 pizzas annually, the restaurant prides itself on using only the finest ingredients, paired with nearly two decades of culinary expertise to deliver remarkable flavor in every dish.

This locally-owned establishment offers a wide range of menu options, including appetizers, salads, specialty pizzas, and scrumptious desserts, all available for take-out and delivery. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, New Brother's Pizza continues to earn the trust of thousands of satisfied diners in the area.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5

(46)

Photo of B Dwayne A.
B Dwayne A.
1/6/2026

My wife and I ordered two cheesesteaks yesterday for supper. She had the supreme with onions and green peppers as well as last tomato and mayonnaise, and I had a basic cheese steak with lettuce...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Kelley W.
Kelley W.
1/3/2026

Ordered a steak and cheese with EXTRA meat for delivery, tipped $12.00. Went inside and opened my container and pulled the pound of lettuce off to reveal the exact puny amount of steak the put on...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of David B.
David B.
4/4/2025

Ordered delivery from these good people and will definitely do so again. Food arrived hot and the driver was very friendly. Even though I was told they were busy, the delivery time was totally...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Cody N.
Cody N.
6/13/2025

The good is the food. I've never really had bad food from this place. I have ordered a lot different items. From their pizza(which can be extremely greasy), to their burgers, to their subs and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Shantel B.
Shantel B.
8/30/2024

Had the most fantastic pizza!!! Ordered their supreme pizza with jalapeños (extra crispy) and it was out of this world. Also had their chicken salad which was delightful. Will definitely be back!!

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Pizza Hut - Closed
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Pizza Hut - Closed

8
"First, the Pizza and Wings were perfect but what I really want to acknowledge was the lady behind the counter when I went inside to pick up our order. This lady was working behind the counter..."
photo of John S.
Domino's Pizza
Pizza restaurants, Eating places

Domino's Pizza

3
•
$
"This is going to be an easy one. Placing an order from a hotel, I was prepared for mess-ups. A lot of places treat travelers indifferently. I experienced this first hand with restaurants in..."
photo of Julie F.
Pizza Hut
Eating places, Pizza restaurants

Pizza Hut

2
•
$
"Awesome fresh out of the oven pizza!This place was kind and took it to our car too! Love this place on vacation."
United States›Virginia›Fishersville›New Brother's Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Advertisement