Steve D.
11/22/2025
Pizza is very good. Did carryout so I'm not sure about the service except our order was done on time. Will definitely go back. The pepperoni was excellent.
NY Pie
$
Open
(180)
Advertisement
Photos
305 Indian Lake Blvd
Hendersonville, TN 37075
NY Pie was opened with the intention of bringing the experience of NY style pizza to Nashville. New York style pizza is characterized by a thin and crispy crust that is achieved through a method of hand-tossing dough & baking on a brick oven. The ability to make a hand tossed dough that is consistently thin is a dying art and is much harder than pizza chefs make it look. As such, NY Pie chefs train for months to become expert pizza makers! NY Pie’s “secret” in staying true to the artform & delivering a first-rate product is simple – only use the freshest and highest quality ingredients (including Grande cheese, fresh vegetables, and delicious meats) and home-make the dough and sauces daily. NY Pie’s dough is made in the store, 50 lbs. of flour at a time.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0180 reviews
andrew d.
5/18/2025
Great staff. Young but attentive, empowered and willing to do what needs to be done. Ordered to-go. Grandma's pie (add sausage on half) Well executed! Shallow, crisp, clean and easy to...
Bryan E.
8/7/2025
Went to New York pie after lunch, but before dinner. It was very slow. Order was done within minutes, hot fresh to the table. Only thing I would recommend is ordering extra cheese.
Lincoln F.
12/21/2025
Supreme Pizza was good, generous toppings, a 7.1 on the Dave Portnoys scale in my opinion. A little on the pricey side compared to other comproable pizzas. We got it delivered so never went inside...
Robert F.
7/28/2025
Got mine to go, can't speak on the ambiance. In town for work it's close to the hotel. Decent toppings But for $32 and some change I expected more than this. The crust is clearly "Burnt". Disappointed
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement