Kelsey L.
11/28/2025
great atmosphere and customer service! food is always on point. great pizza options! the owners are always present and engaged with the customers. Would recommend to all family and friends.
Uncommon Pizza
$$
Closed
(67)
Advertisement
Photos
616 Paxton Pl Ste 104
Lititz, PA 17543
UnCommon Pizza, founded in 2007, has become one of the Lancaster/Lititz/Manheim Township area's favorite spots for casual dining. UnCommon features award-winning pizza (the Buffalo Chicken Pizza is outstanding), wings, made-from-scratch soups, sandwiches, appetizers, homemande ice cream and full bar service. The restaurant has a dining room and outdoor patio. Carryout and delivery service is available.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.567 reviews
Will A.
6/24/2025
New owners, new menu for humans and pups, and welcoming new vibes! I love their music bingo and trivia on Wednesdays and they have the best ranch in the state!
Jackie A.
5/9/2024
Aww man, I hate to rip apart a privately owned establishment, but this pizza just wasn't good. The positives first - our waitress was super nice; the lunch specials were wallet friendly and the...
Cheryl B.
6/27/2025
I was a huge advocate of uncommon pizza for years and it was always my go to. We would spend hundreds of dollars there on delivery for our kids' birthday parties. The last few times we have...
Lea K.
5/11/2025
The negative: pizza is not great, but edible. Fries taste like frozen freezer burn, I've had better from my air fryer. The service was insanely slow - it seemed like they just assumed their wait...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement