Teresa R.
11/27/2025
I grew up in New Castle, Pennsylvania and have eaten at M&P Coney Island for most of my life. You can't go wrong with anything you order here! The chili dogs, chili hamburgers, kraut dogs,...
M&P Coney Island
$
Open
(34)
Advertisement
Photos
2654 Ellwood Rd
New Castle, PA 16101
M&P Coney Island, located in New Castle, PA, has been a cherished fixture since 1923, serving some of the nation's best chili and hot dogs. Founded by Greek immigrants John Mitsos and George Papazekos, the family-owned establishment has built a reputation for its simple yet satisfying menu featuring burgers, hot dogs, fries, and fish sandwiches.
The eatery is well-known for its famous chili sauce, which is available for purchase online and at various locations in western Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Buffalo, New York. With a nostalgic atmosphere and friendly service, M&P Coney Island continues to attract both locals and visitors alike, making it a beloved destination for American comfort food.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.534 reviewsElenoar R.
12/7/2025
MP Coney Island Shenango Twp I've been trying for months to get basic food safety issues fixed and nothing has changed. As someone with experience in many other fast food restaurants I was...
Makayla J.
12/7/2025
Terrible service dirty environment and rude staff who don't follow protoco. Would not recomend
Wesley F.
2/5/2025
Would give zero stars if i could. Beware of these dogs. For the cost this is a great disappointment! "I went to the new store in Shenango. These are the worst hot dogs I have ever tried to eat....
Lori T.
11/8/2024
Their new address is 2654 Ellwood Rd New Castle PA. The hot dogs were cold, the fries so salty and cold. The counter by the drink machine was very filthy as well as the fountain dispensers...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement