Uncle Primo's

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(100)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

435 Minnich Ave NW
New Philadelphia, OH 44663

Uncle Primo’s in New Philadelphia presents a delectable menu featuring blackened tuna, teriyaki salmon, filet, strip steaks, premium pork chops, and chicken breasts, all cooked to perfection. The 24-ounce ribeye steak, finished with a special grill sauce, is a standout offering. Pasta lovers can delight in house-made lasagna, while seafood enthusiasts can savor grilled Ahi tuna, sautéed seafood, and blackened walleye. Each entrée includes the renowned “all you can eat” salad with house dressing, complemented by a full bar serving local brewery draft beers and homemade desserts like cream puffs and cheesecake.

Set in a historic building dating back to the 1880s, Uncle Primo’s initially housed a family of seven and has since been transformed into a cozy dining spot. The bar area, added in 1994 using reclaimed bricks, enhances the dining experience. The restaurant’s back room, once an outdoor deck, was enclosed in 1995, providing a unique dining space. Following a major fire in 2011, Uncle Primo’s expanded with an additional parking lot in 2020, ensuring a comfortable visit for patrons.

Guest reviews consistently rave about Uncle Primo’s exceptional dishes and service, with highlights including perfectly cooked strip steak, delectable seafood offerings, and divine desserts like cream puffs and tiramisu. The warm atmosphere and attentive staff make for an unforgettable dining experience, making Uncle Primo’s a must-visit destination for food lovers in the New Philadelphia area.

Generated from the website content

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5100 reviews
Photo of Scott L.
Scott L.
12/8/2025

Friendly efficient service, very reasonable prices, and excellent food. My favorite is peppers and sausage with pasta, but they are known for great lasagna.

Photo of Dennis G.
Dennis G.
11/30/2025

We have been to Uncle Primo's twice. Both times we had a positive experience. The front of the house was very efficient. Both times the restaurant was quite busy but we were promptly seated on...

Photo of James W.
James W.
5/8/2025

We found this country gem thanks to Yelp on our trip back home. Both food and service were exceptional. Ashley, our server, suggested our lunch order be the soup of the day, a delicious Cream of...

Photo of Desireé H.
Desireé H.
8/14/2025

I love having dinner here whenever I'm in the area! Lovely service and excellent dishes. They're always busy but can always get us seated. Tonight we sat on the patio for the first time and it was...

Alicia N.
11/27/2025

My favorite restaurant in town!! Especially love their crab cakes and the sauce that comes with. And the service and environment is always stellar. I know they switched owners and I haven't been...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesOhioNew PhiladelphiaUncle Primo's

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement