Sammy's New York Bagels

$
Closed
yelp logo

(57)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

600 N Cassady Ave Ste E
Columbus, OH 43219
+1 (614) 252-1551
http://www.sammysbagels.net

Sammy's New York Bagels is a Columbus-based bagel shop offering convenient next-day home delivery in the central Ohio area with a minimum order amount of $20. Each bagel is carefully shaped and kettle-boiled in small batches, ensuring a beautiful sheen on the outside and soft chewiness on the inside.

The production facility is located near downtown Columbus, Ohio, and orders must be placed by 3:00 pm for next-day delivery by 7:30 am. A small fee of $3 is added to orders totaling $20.00-$29.99 to cover delivery maintenance costs.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Find related places

Restaurants

Reviews

yelp logo
4.557 reviews
Photo of Ted B.
Ted B.
10/13/2025

Excellent bagels. We especially like the onion bagels, but the garlic and everything bagels are not too far behind.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Danielle H.
Danielle H.
11/22/2024

What a great idea. A friend had these delivered to my doorstep. They arrived by 5am, complete packaged and placed into a cooler on my front porch. It was wonderful waking up to fresh bagels on my...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Robin F.
Robin F.
12/1/2024

Many years ago I shopped at Sammys in New Rochelle, NY. When he came to Columbus I couldn't get there fast enough. When I moved back to Columbus this year I couldn't wait to order bagels from...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Michael G.
Michael G.
12/23/2023

My fave bagel in Central Ohio. They have no retail store presence, but you can order on the website for delivery! We did a large order that I ordered a week in advance for delivery on a Saturday....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jennifer R.
Jennifer R.
3/15/2023

I wish I could give more than five stars. These are THE best bagels and scallion cream cheese I have ever had. They are way better than the bagels I had in NY last year. Also, Sammy's has restored...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Services, nec, nec, Carry-out only (except pizza) restaurant

Addisu Bakery & Carryout

$
Panaderia El Panes is a beloved bakery in Columbus, GA, known for its fresh and delicious pan and cakes made with the finest ingredients. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, they create a warm and inviting atmosphere where people of all backgrounds can indulge in their delectable treats. From skillfully decorated wedding cakes to mouthwatering mini desserts and pies, Panaderia El Panes offers a wide range of menu items that are baked fresh daily. Their dedication to using tested recipes ensures exceptional taste and quality in every bite, making them a go-to destination for satisfying treats in Columbus, GA.Generated from the website
Lindsey's Bakery
Eating places, Grills (eating places)

Lindsey's Bakery

73
•
$
"This place rocks! Great to have in Circleville and vegan donut options! There are numerous options. The value and staff are amazing. It's a must visit place if you come to Circleville."
photo of Harvey L.
Golden Donuts & Diner
Eating places, Diner, Doughnuts

Golden Donuts & Diner

64
•
$
"We went for the first time after reading about this being a "hidden gem". It doesn't look like much from the exterior, but the food and service were both very good. The portions were very large,..."
United States›Ohio›Columbus›Sammy's New York Bagels

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Advertisement