LuAnn C.
10/23/2025
Service was good. Waitress was pleasant. The food, however, was a different story. We ordered the broasted chicken dinner. The chicken was over done. The stuffing was bland. The coleslaw was...
Der Dutchman
$$
Open
(350)
Advertisement
Photos
445 S Jefferson Ave
Plain City, OH 43064
Many of our customers are regulars who eat at Der Dutchman, or carry out from our menu, more than once a week. We’re their “kitchen away from home”—and with good reason. Der Dutchman serves exactly the kind of simple food associated with home cooking—hearty, satisfying, made-from-scratch meals that make everyone happy to pull up to the table. It’s tradition you can taste. Our menu features Amish cooking at its best. Sample our mouthwatering broasted chicken, tender roast beef and ham, real mashed potatoes, stuffing and vegetables. Save room for dessert, though, with choices of pies, cakes, bread puddings. For a unique experience, dine in an Amish Buggy situated in the dining room! Whether you make Plain City your home or you’re just passing through, you’re always welcome to join the regulars for a hearty meal and a heaping helping of hospitality. Come on in and let Der Dutchman Restaurant be your home kitchen away from home.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5350 reviews
Brian K.
11/26/2025
With Thanksgiving right around the corner, my wife and I decided it was the perfect time to place our annual pie order from one of our favorite Amish-based spots: Der Dutchman. When we pulled into...
Kurt H.
7/25/2025
I have eaten at many Amish restaurants and was overall disappointed with this one.. First of all, it's cavernous and very clean with a corporate sterility to it. It's almost like going into a...
Madison S.
11/1/2025
Ventured out to Der Dutchman for the breakfast buffet. Couldn't believe how big this place was! It was run very smoothly. Didn't have to wait to be sat and the server came pretty promptly. The...
John S.
11/24/2025
I don't live in Ohio anymore, but always get excited to go to Der Dutchman. The quality of the food hasn't changed in my opinion, and in fact the number of offerings on the buffet have increased....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement