Nick S.
12/2/2025
Carfagna's is seriously the best! I went to the Bar & Ristorante not too long ago and had a great meal with the family! The dining space is inviting and the staff is very welcoming and go out of...
Carfagna's Ristorante
$$
Closed
(441)
Advertisement
Photos
1440 Gemini Pl
Columbus, OH 43240
Carfagna's Ristorante, located in Columbus, Ohio, is a premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine, renowned for both its imported and homemade goods. The establishment also serves as a cohesive market, offering a diverse range of culinary options from a whiskey menu to family value meat bundles, alongside a vibrant atmosphere enriched by live music and regular events.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0441 reviews
Jamie B.
6/22/2025
Today we had family in town from St. Louis and after all the pictures we shared of Carfagna's to them it was finally time to have their amazing Stromboli or pizza. WRONG!!!.....We were told they...
Amy C.
11/18/2025
Everytime we are in Columbus/Westerville we eat here. It's an experience. The restaurant is also a huge Italian market like nothing I've seen before. I defy anyone to eat there and not buy...
Jennifer R.
5/6/2025
Service - 10 Atmosphere - 6 Price - 6 Food - 5 Italian market is still fantastic in the new space. Wine store was busy with tastings. Lots of bourbons. Food needs seasoning, more time in the...
Justin J.
11/22/2025
My girlfriend (who is basically a model) and I decided we wanted to mangia mangia mangia some good old fashioned ristorante food. We started with the meatballs. They meat mix was a little too...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement