Butter Maid Bakery

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(165)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

425 Boardman Canfield Rd
Youngstown, OH 44512
+1 (844) 688-7655
http://www.buttermaidbakery.com

Butter Maid Bakery is a 5th generation small family-owned and operated bakery that has been handcrafting their products the old-fashioned way for over 150 years. They use the finest ingredients, including real sugar, honey, butter, eggs, milk, and nuts directly from the farm, to ensure the highest quality in their baked goods.

With a commitment to delivering the best, Butter Maid Bakery offers a wide selection of delicious European pastries and cookies, including their popular Kolachi rolls and handmade sugar butter cookies. Customers rave about the authentic taste and nostalgic memories that their products bring, making Butter Maid Bakery a go-to destination for those seeking traditional, homemade treats.

Generated from the website

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5165 reviews
Mary Beth
11/22/2025

Buttermaid bakery provides my family and friends with the old fashioned Kohl's hi rolls but most of all the wonderful apricot cookies!! We all try to steal and get as many as we can!! Love this...

Read more on Yelp
Mary S.
11/21/2025

My husband's favorite sweets include your poppyseed & nut rolls. He was born in Budapest & raised in Kosice, Slovakia post WWII. Your bakery deserves a ! Thank you, Attila & Mary Szullo

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Charlene M.
Charlene M.
1/4/2026

MY SAILOR NEVER GOT HIS COOKIE PACKAGE! I ordered 2 products. 1 military box 2 dozen cookies for my son, who couldn't be home with us for Christmas and we all miss him so much. I wanted my son to...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Mary M.
Mary M.
12/18/2025

We have ordered the nut roll, the butter balls and the peanut butter buckeyes. We have never been disappointed by the quality and the taste of Butter Maid Bakery's products. The nut rolls remind...

Read more on Yelp
Paul N.
11/30/2025

Over rated over priced and the family shtick is only if you're from a very disfunctional family. End crust was tough but the center had a great fusion of poppyseed and honey. Add my...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Casa Dolce Bakery
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Casa Dolce Bakery

79
•
$
"On a Sunday, I brought a cake. Upon entering, I was immediately greeted and helped. The person offered to write a message for me on the cake. While I waited, I was able to see all of the yummy..."
photo of Monica O.
Pink Box
Chinese restaurant, Eating places

Pink Box

156
•
$
"Pork floss bun is the best i've ever had. Fragrant and savory, yet creamy. I ordered a taro cake and the owner was making it even though they hurt their arm and had to go to the urgent care. They..."
Aladdin's Bakery and Market
Eating places, Greek restaurant, Seasonings and spices

Aladdin's Bakery and Market

36
•
$
"A wonderful place to indulge or try many middle eastern foods, because the prices are unbelievably..."
photo of Brendastarshine
United States›Ohio›Youngstown›Butter Maid Bakery

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement