Allen B.
11/20/2025
Pizza is great was crispy but not burnt the breadsticks are amazing and the price isnt bad. Customer service was amazing. the guy with the beard is super nice
The Original NY Pizza
$
Closed
(67)
Advertisement
Photos
831 Bass Pro Ln
Cary, NC 27513
The Original New York Pizza in Cary, NC brings a taste of the Big Apple to North Carolina since 1991, offering a wide variety of selections from Calzones to Sicilian pizza, all made with premium Wisconsin cheese and freshly packed Italian tomatoes.
With a commitment to using the finest ingredients, including fresh vegetables and daily-made dough, The Original NY Pizza has been recognized as the best pizza in Western Wake by Maggy Awards and Cary Magazine, solidifying its reputation as the go-to spot for authentic New York-style pizza.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.567 reviews
Alex G.
11/22/2025
The pizza in this place is so damn good. It's definitely legit NY thin crust. Service is , always and it had an old pizzeria vibe to it. The square Sicilian slice is out of this world also.
Steve S.
10/29/2024
Friendly guys behind the counter! Originally from NY and have been living in Seattle area for a decade. Whenever I travel to the east coast I'm always on the lookout for good pizza (can't be...
Mady J.
8/12/2025
Very well may be my new favorite pizza place. Slight crunch with each bite, soft stretchy cheese, and the tomato sauce ugh so good. I only got one slice of a cheese and it was phenomenal. Vibe is...
Isaiah R.
8/3/2025
No hair nets, and no gloves. Bare hands see in cheese bins, staff was not groomed and didn't look like had good hygiene. Left when I saw his bare hands digging in the cheese bins. Rather not get sick
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement