The Cookie Odyssey

yelp logo

(17)

Advertisement

Photos

1414 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10021

Reviews

yelp logo
4.517 reviews
Photo of Melissa G.
Melissa G.
8/15/2025

I was in the mood for sweets when I walked past The Cookie Odyssey. Everything looked good, I decided on a pecan pie cookie and a chocolate chip muffin top, both were really fresh and delicious....

Photo of Dillon L.
Dillon L.
10/17/2025

Friend brought us here after dinner and wow the cookies are good. Order the original and your taste buds will thank you, one of the best cookies I've ever had. The balance of sweet, chocolate,...

Photo of Whitney D.
Whitney D.
8/5/2025

This cookie store just opened in the area. There is no seating really to enjoy your cookies or coffee. There is a small bench by the window. It is super cute and very clean. The person working...

Photo of Steph W.
Steph W.
11/30/2025

The establishment is small but there is a small area to eat. The display of cookies looked amazing. There was a sampler dish to try some of the cookies. We opted for the Oreo which was just cooked...

Photo of Aleena A.
Aleena A.
12/8/2025

Delicious cookie experience. A warm inviting smell and a small store (apparently their first location was in FiDi). Allegedly the oldest cookie shop in NYC. Best part is that there a mini...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkNew YorkThe Cookie Odyssey

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement