Joe H.
9/28/2025
Always a great BEC from this absolute staple of the community. 10/10 will be back again!
Stuff-A-Bagel
$$
Closed
(92)
Advertisement
Photos
425 Montauk Hwy
West Islip, NY 11795
Stuff-A-Bagel, located in West Islip, NY, is renowned for transforming the classic bagel into a variety of delightful meal options. Customers can choose from an array of fresh bagels and a wide range of toppings, creating personalized taste experiences.
The establishment prides itself on quality ingredients and offers a selection that includes not only bagels but also sandwiches and breakfast items. Whether tackling a busy morning or looking for a quick lunch, Stuff-A-Bagel caters to a diverse clientele with its innovative approach to a beloved staple.
Generated from the website
Reviews
2.092 reviews
Sarah M.
7/9/2024
This place is lackluster. When I walked in I thought they were closed. Literally no happy faces in this place and it seems product is low. Their televisions screens were off and it was awkwardly...
Judy S.
11/12/2025
bagels hard cream cheese tasted old used to be good not anymore my son and I were sick all day after 2 bites
Katelyn B.
1/9/2025
Terrible, small bagels, ordered an egg everything toasted and bagel on it. Wasn't toasted, 1 little piece of bacon on it but let's put 3 lbs of cream cheese on it. How does that even make sense....
Jesse B.
3/25/2024
Updating my one star review from 4yrs ago. Stuff A Bagel is under new ownership/management. Everything is made in-store, bagels, coffee cakes, and muffins. Store is nice and clean and the new...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement