Shelter Island Country Club

S.I.C.C. ("The Goat") is a time machine. For those who complain about and don't understand what Shelter Island Country Club is..it's one of the last remaining "pasture courses" in the USA. At the...

You will laugh as you drive up the hill looking at the course, but give it a try. The fairways are in a natural condition, but the greens are in excellent shape. It's a hilly course and most of...

We did not enjoy our experience here. Not well maintained and Almost all blind shots to the green. Cart prices are outrageous and misleading on-line. We paid $20 PER PERSON for a cart. Also, the...

Disappointing experience at Goat Hill Golf Course. Not only was the course in poor condition - overgrown tee boxes, directional flags identical to the greens' flags and pricing was that was...