Food

Setauket Pastaria

Closed

(125)

Call

Website

Photos

4082 Nesconset Hwy

East Setauket, NY 11733

+1 (631) 476-8600

http://www.setauketpastaria.com

Setauket Pastaria is about delicious Italian food served in abundant portions. Owner Vincent Milano created this restaurant as a place to celebrate family and festive occasions in a warm and beautiful setting with attentive service that makes you feel at home. Artists from Argentina and Italy have fashioned our hand painted wall murals to recreate an Italian village. But it is the sights, sounds, smell, and flavors that will take you away to Italy. Gourmet pizzas line the counter and overflowing pasta bowls fill the dining room. Our menu has a wide array of pizza, pasta, chicken, veal, seafood, and steak. Whether you eat in out take out you'll love our food. Open since January 2002 we are constantly developing to accommodate the needs of our guests, after all We're Family! Check out our weekly specials!

Reviews

3.0125 reviews

Ashley W.

1/29/2025

I personally love their penne ala vodka and their lunch specials are top tier. So many good choices daily. I recommend their chicken roll. I can only speak for the to-go I don't dine in here....

Read more on Yelp

Carolyn W.

11/26/2025

I've been coming here 10+ years and the pizza has changed from excellent to terrible. I don't know what they're doing but the pizza is overloaded with horrible poor quality cheese (and now the...

Read more on Yelp

Djudma C.

7/24/2024

Ordered lasagna through DoorDash... double thumbs down. Undercooked noodles drowning in pasta sauce with very questionable meat. Garlic knots were okay.

Read more on Yelp

Joey M.

8/31/2024

Please see my review in the pictures below. Such a disappointment and quite frankly unacceptable to loyal customers. As you can see, most people agree. Not an acceptable "Italian Restaurant"...

Read more on Yelp

Anthony William D.

8/30/2024

You live and you learn. Let me start off by saying the service was awesome, the restaurant itself is nice. But when I tell you how disappointed I was at their dinner. I've gone here for pizza and...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

See a problem?