Dom G.
1/7/2026
Pretty decent NY pizza - ordered a cheese pie, a pepperoni and a hot boi to have between 4 adults and 3 kids. Also ordered a few sides to start the meal - meatballs and chicken parm. All very...
Scarr's Pizza
$
Open
(1,211)
Advertisement
Photos
35 Orchard St
New York, NY 10002
Scarr's Pizza is a pizzeria located in New York, NY, known for its retro ambiance and a menu featuring pies, slices, and subs made with modern ingredients. Their offerings include traditional options like Sicilian slices and unique choices such as pepperoni jalapeno and beef pepperoni. Scarr's aims to provide a fresh take on classic pizza, highlighting the quality of their all-natural, stone-milled flour.
In addition to their menu, Scarr's Pizza has introduced their first-ever cookbook and offers catering services for events and parties. The establishment is dedicated to serving delicious food in a welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for pizza lovers in the city.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0(1,211)
Vatsal S.
1/8/2026
After so much hype on social media, we went here and essentially got a Costco cheese slice. The similarity was uncanny. So if you're missing Costco cheese slice in your life, go here! otherwise...
Walter M.
1/6/2026
Scarr's may not be one of the big pizza names in NYC, but it should be because it's doing things the right way and sticking to traditions. Quality ingredients from sourcing organic local flour,...
Alyssa W.
12/21/2025
Try the hot boi - it's salty, a little spicy and a little sweet, great combo. The tomato sauce on the margherita is a bit lacking but lots of cheese so if you like a cheesier slice, that could be...
Pia V.
12/11/2025
How have I not reviewed Scarr's?! So you just know by all the reviews that this pizza is pretty prime. The Grandma slice is, by far, my favorite but they do run out of it. Other than that, you...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement