Hunter W.
12/6/2025
The bad thing about Scarr's is the line. Then. you eat it and see why they have the line. It is really great pizza. I have found ways to avoid the line but I am not sharing. Sorry/not sorry.
Scarr's Pizza
$
Closed
(1,195)
Advertisement
Photos
35 Orchard St
New York, NY 10002
Scarr's Pizza is a pizzeria located in New York, NY, known for its retro ambiance and a menu featuring pies, slices, and subs made with modern ingredients. Their offerings include traditional options like Sicilian slices and unique choices such as pepperoni jalapeno and beef pepperoni. Scarr's aims to provide a fresh take on classic pizza, highlighting the quality of their all-natural, stone-milled flour.
In addition to their menu, Scarr's Pizza has introduced their first-ever cookbook and offers catering services for events and parties. The establishment is dedicated to serving delicious food in a welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for pizza lovers in the city.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.01,195 reviews
Dalena D.
12/3/2025
Texture of the pizza is pretty solid and their pizza tastes like a high quality slice shop! Rating my fav to least fav: Hotboi Dj Clark Kent (Sicilian) Vodka pesto Margherita Make sure to make...
Guy K.
11/21/2025
In A Nutshell: -Scarr's is a nice representation of a NY pizza. -I enjoyed 4 different slices of their cheese, pepperoni, Margherita & hot boy pizzas. -I loved the taste of each of these,...
Julie Ying X.
12/4/2025
I came here since everyone raves about this place. The place seemed cool with its arcade games and old school interior. We ordered the medium size (12 inch) margarita pie with mushroom topping....
Dessa R.
12/4/2025
With anything in NYC, be prepared for a wait at this popular pizza spot in the city. They sell ny the slice, which is nice when you don't feel like having a whole pie. Be prepared for a longer...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement