Riesterer's Bakery

If you're into old-fashioned bakery charm with a huge variety of freshly baked goods and classic New York baked-good flavors, Riesterer's is a must-visit bakery on Long Island. Go early in the day...

What used to be a go-to place for the last over 40 years has declined greatly. There is too much competition to keep going to a place who sells napoleons with dry filo dough and old cupcakes....

I came here a few times in the past few months and I was disappointed. So much to choose from but the staff seem unfriendly. The premade cakes in the display are not priced and when you ask...

I was looking back at my past pictures and came across my cake from my baby shower from August 2023. At the time, I didn't know where it was from until earlier tonight. I looked at the name...

When I called asking for a cake to resemble an everything bagel with lox and cream cheese...this could've gone very poorly. Riesterer's knocked it out of the park. Insane cake. Well done! Also I...