Just lovely. Great location, fantastic views, delicious food, comfy rooms, kind staff, perfect ambiance. It doesn't feel too small or too overwhelming and it's easy to get around. The dinner...
The Pridwin Hotel
(84)
Advertisement
Photos
Also at this address
Reviews
Booked one the famous summer Wednesday BBQ dinner, we were very excited. It was cancelled due to rain, which is understandable. But I never got back my $250 prepayment for 3 ? Okay cancel it...
extra 10% resort fees added on (without warning at time of booking) for a poor array of resort amenities: no cushions on lounge chairs at poolside, a so-so concrete tennis court, a few plastic...
Gorgeous views, high quality and excellent service. This is an amazing spot on Shelter Island to have a bite to eat, to take in views, to spend time with family and friends.
What a shame to have to do this review. I am writing this on behalf of my 81 year old parents who have been coming to Shelter Island for over 40 years. My dad booked a room here for 4 nights.....
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement

