Caitlin G.
10/16/2025
Outstanding! Fresh, delicious, charming! Fresh bread. I had the tuna melt that was absolutely perfect.
Pickler Sandwich Shop
$$
Closed
(409)
Advertisement
Photos
216 E 45th St
New York, NY 10017
Pickler Sandwich Shop is a vibrant eatery located in New York, NY, specializing in a diverse array of delicious sandwiches. The shop also offers online ordering for the convenience of its customers, ensuring a seamless experience for those on the go.
In addition to their sandwich offerings, Pickler Sandwich Shop provides catering services, making it a great option for events and gatherings. With a focus on quality and flavor, this local establishment aims to satisfy the cravings of sandwich lovers in the community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.5409 reviews
Brian W.
9/11/2025
Good Rachel sandwich. Pretty fast, and everyone was really nice. Just about what you want. Pickle self-serve was cool. I got a couple of full-on sour spears. One was so awesome; the other less so....
Kara B.
9/14/2025
The door and the website both say they open at 10:30 on weekends. Showed up at 10:35 and the doors were locked, the lights were off, with no intention on opening anytime soon....
Jenna H.
3/24/2025
Solid place for good sandwiches with a cool old school vibe. I was attracted to the self-serve pickle station and decided to come in to try it. It was around 10:30 AM so I was torn between the...
Rob K.
11/29/2025
Omg, I can't believe I've lived a block away for five years and only found this place a few months ago. Now it's part of my on-the-way-to-work routine. I stop in here, place my order on their big...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement