Leah O.
11/21/2025
Petee's is the best. Every pie I've ever tried here is so good. We were in the neighborhood and decided to have a slice in stores. There's not much seating but it was just me & my partner so we...
Petee's Cafe LLC
$$
Closed
(145)
Advertisement
Photos
505 Myrtle Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11205
Petee's Café, located in Brooklyn and the Lower East Side of New York, specializes in delivering delicious, handcrafted pies, showcasing a commitment to quality and taste. Customers can enjoy the convenience of ordering for delivery or pickup, making it easy to indulge in their sweet and savory offerings.
With a focus on community engagement, Petee's Café invites patrons to join their mailing list for updates and offers while maintaining a presence on social media platforms like Instagram. The café also provides options for national shipping, making their pies accessible to a wider audience beyond New York City.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0(145)
Miranda M.
1/3/2026
This weekend, I had 2 slices of pie from here (Petee's Pie is what this location is listed as online): a Wild Maine Blueberry Slice and a Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice. Upon delivery, we...
Serena X.
12/31/2025
Tried a cappuccino and blueberry pie as I was walking in the neighborhood, and was pleasantly surprised with the winter special pies available as well. The blueberry pie was not too sweet, and the...
Kevin B.
1/6/2026
The Black Almond Bottom Pie is FIRE. Love the other different flavors too. They also have good coffee here to hit the spot, or some milk. Our first time here, and the pies are not very expensive...
Amy W.
11/12/2024
CUTEST pie shop in Brooklyn! Super lovely and friendly staff, and a large selection of pies by the slice and pie. They also have a very well-priced coffee and tea menu! The interior is tight but...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement