Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant

Permanently closed
tripadvisor logo

(14)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

1 Main St
Garnerville, NY 10923
+1 (845) 429-4862
http://www.oiprestaurant.com
Every ingredient in our food is individually hand-selected for amazing taste and quality, remniscent of the old country. Nothing else compares. You'll fall in love with it all, from our mouthwatering pizzas to our creamy fettuccini alfredo, even our fresh garden salads. There's something for all to enjoy.

Also at this address

Reviews

tripadvisor logo
4.014 reviews
Photo of O95GUdennisb
Service bad
2/19/2022

Last week I ordered a round Sicilian and they said they got the order wrong and would bake me anoth...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of SuckOne4Me
Horrible Service
12/10/2020

I order a salad and they forget the dressing EVERY time. I order chicken fingers and ask for hot sau...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Photo of April L
Lunch
9/22/2019

Ordered many times from OIP. Have never been disappointed with service. The assortment of pies they ...

Read more on Tripadvisor
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Famous Ben's Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Famous Ben's Pizza

431
•
$
"Famous Ben's Pizza completely blew me away. This was hands down the best pizza I have ever had. The Palermo slice is unmatched. It is so simple with breadcrumbs, onion, and garlic, but somehow it..."
photo of Joseph C.
Russo's House of Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Russo's House of Pizza

15
•
$
"My husband and I visited Russo’s the other day after following them for quite sometime on Instagram ..."
photo of Sammyjo225
Roberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Caterers

Roberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

7
•
$
"I'm not sure about the rest of the menu, but if the quality follows that of the pizza? It's a winner. We ordered a Sicilian and regular pies... and they were great. The Sicilian in particular was..."
photo of Jamey F.
United States›New York›Garnerville›Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement