Old Mill Inn

Went on a July Wed night. Hard to get a reservation. TLDR: expensive and not memorable. Expected the pricing. But since that's a given, the food/experience has to be worthwhile. Setting is great...

We were in the area for engagement photos- asked about local shops and were recommended the Old Mill Inn. It was late on a Tuesday evening but there was plenty of availability. Staff was so nice....

This was my first time to the Old Mill since its renovation. They did a nice job keeping the feel of the old place while updating the restaurant to current standards. Great views of Mattituck...

Great renovation, the food and drinks are outstanding, I personally support their policy of no children.

Sat at the Chefs table. Yes, that is now a thing. Chef was engaging and informative. The guy who clears the meals and wears a hat is not nice. He should be retrained. Food amazing. Worth a try but...