Food

Old Mill

Closed

(22)

Call

Website

Photos

[6152 - 6180] Depot St

Alfred Station, NY 14803

+1 (607) 587-9060

http://www.onedepotstreet.com

The Old Mill Inn is a charming American pub and eatery located in Alfred Station, NY. Housed within the historic structure of a former grain mill, this quintessential small town establishment has become a beloved gathering spot for both locals and visitors. Under new management, The Old Mill Inn offers an expanded menu featuring classic American cuisine and a variety of traditional favorites, inviting guests to experience the warm and welcoming atmosphere of this re-imagined pub.

Nestled in the heart of Alfred Station, The Old Mill Inn is a testament to the town's rich history and community spirit. With its rustic charm and comfortable ambiance, this establishment has evolved into a go-to destination for those seeking a taste of authentic American fare. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch or a hearty dinner, The Old Mill Inn promises a delightful dining experience that captures the essence of small town hospitality.

Generated from the website

Reviews

3.522 reviews

Dee C.

9/19/2021

It's slim pickings out in this area when looking for food. My husband did some digging around on Yelp and found this place. When we walked in, we were like "oh Lord , what did we just walk...

Read more on Yelp

Eric C.

10/4/2025

I would have given 5 stars. Food was great! Had pb&j wings and they were amazing! But staff seemed confused and lost about who was waiting on what tables.

Read more on Yelp

Ward J.

3/20/2025

I think I have just witnessed the worst thing I've ever seen at a restaurant. We were sitting there waiting for our food and this sweet elderly couple walks in the door out of the rain with big...

Read more on Yelp

Vicki D.

6/22/2025

Had to stop in to see how they fixed it up. Great cold beer and wings. A must stop when I visit Alfred. I remember it from years ago. Nice, cozy spot.

Read more on Yelp

Katie S.

10/20/2025

Easily the worst place I've ever eaten at. Avoid the Mac and cheese it's just noodles with dried up cheese. Waited over 3 hours to do apps dinner and desert. Over an hour between each meal. Spent...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

See a problem?

Bars and lounges, Eating places

Alex's College Spot

Alex's College Spot is a vibrant pizzeria located in Alfred, NY, perfect for students and locals alike. Known for its delicious, handcrafted pizzas made with fresh ingredients, this cozy eatery offers a welcoming atmosphere ideal for gathering with friends. With a variety of toppings and specialty pies, there's something to satisfy every palate. Don't forget to check out their daily specials and enjoy a slice in this energetic college town! Generated from this place's information

Bar (drinking places), Eating places, Grills (eating places)

Alex's College Spot

Alex's College Spot in Alfred, NY is a local establishment that offers a variety of services to college students, providing a convenient and comfortable space for studying, socializing, and relaxation. With a focus on creating a welcoming environment, Alex's College Spot aims to cater to the needs of students, offering amenities and resources that enhance their college experience.Generated from the website