Daniele B.
12/17/2019
As for pizza in the area. This place is number 1 in my eyes. The crust is crispy, the sauce is divine and the topping portions are fantastic! I have gotten slices from there in the past. I love...
New York Pizzeria
$
Closed
(17)
Advertisement
Photos
200 S Peterboro St
Canastota, NY 13032
New York Pizzeria offers a selection of pizza known for its great taste, attracting visitors looking for a satisfying meal. The restaurant aims to provide a quality dining experience with its signature pizzas that often leave guests pleased. However, some menu items, like the antipasto, may not meet expectations based on customer feedback.
In addition to pizza, New York Pizzeria serves various dishes to complement its main offerings. The staff strives to assist customers, although service experiences may vary. Overall, the pizzeria is a noteworthy stop for those exploring the area and seeking a delicious slice.
Generated from the web
Reviews
3.517 reviewsJeff E.
4/30/2025
Been a customer for many years waited over an hour and a half for a pizza and I live down the street I called to ask where the pizza was. They said they were really busy. They never told me that...
Julie M.
5/25/2024
Wrong order. Always order the same thing sausage,mushrooms, onions-was given pepperoni instead of sausage . Crust was flat like it wasn't given time to rise. Chicken wings dark brown and super dry,
Andrew S.
5/6/2022
Amazing little stop for lunch on the way to the Syracuse airport. Two slices for and a bottle of pop for $6.50 was a steal. If your are near here check it out.
Patrick D.
7/30/2023
Welcome to NEW YORK it's a crime everyone can't give these folks a try. I drove 25 minutes on a 'what the heck ' journey. Would drive an hour. These folks nailed the crust had pizza and a calzone.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement