Katie B.
10/17/2025
They had some of the best apple cider donuts and chocolate chip cookies I've ever had!
Milk Pail
$$$
Open
(65)
Advertisement
Photos
1346 Montauk Hwy
Water Mill, NY 11976
Milk Pail Fresh Market, located in Water Mill, NY, offers a delightful selection of fresh produce, baked goods, and seasonal items. Known for its unique apple varieties not found at other orchards on Long Island, the market provides a charming experience for visitors seeking quality and freshness.
In addition to its market offerings, Milk Pail features a U-Pick experience for apples and pumpkins, allowing guests to enjoy the harvest firsthand. The market also provides holiday goodies and gift packs, ensuring a memorable shopping experience throughout the year.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.565 reviewsBrian P.
10/12/2024
Not that racist! I was hesitant after reading Yogi's 1 star review, but the employees were friendly, delicious apple cider donuts made to order. I kinda wish they were a little racist but these...
Chris M.
2/16/2025
Went with my family to Milk Pail in October of last year to go apple picking. Although the staff behind the counter could have been a bit friendlier, it was a great experience. There were several...
Estina R.
7/30/2020
What a lovely spot to grab a range of items from fruit (...very beautifully grown, special items), huge selection of dairy and cheese and baked goods....nothing quite like it in the area. So happy...
Sonia P.
9/2/2022
Cute little place with a LOT of different yummy looking products from cheeses to specialty crackers and of course donuts!!! Quite overpriced but that's about par for the course in the Hamptons!!...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement