J P.
10/25/2025
Tried Mike's underground pizza for the first time today and my wife and I loved it. Delivery was a little interesting lol
Mikes Pizza
Closed
(59)
Advertisement
Photos
217 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701
An Amityville tradition since 1969. Original - Classic - Delicious. Text your orders for delivery only to 516-589-2523. Orders by text only Delivery within 5 miles, but Pick-Up Spots available within 5-mile radius
Also at this address
Reviews
4.559 reviews
Diana M.
2/8/2025
PIZZA HEART PIES if you're looking for a fun and delicious way to spend Valentine's Day, Mike's pizzas got you covered! Offering four different kinds of heart-shaped pies, each one is sure to...
Joe H.
2/15/2025
Still one of the greatest! Valentine's Day did not disappoint with this awesome . Not only was the food great, the driver was sporting a shirt and tie with a rose garnished pizza box. It's these...
Brian G.
10/24/2025
Killer Sicilian pie from mikes, a bit of a unique experience picking up the pie for a guy my age but ay what can i say the pizza is worth it!
ADAM Y.
11/12/2025
The best pizza east of Brooklyn. Always fresh and tasty. The Detroit is legit but the regular is just as good.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement