David D.
12/30/2025
Best pizza in NYC that we found - and we looked hard! Absolutely fantastic! Small and intimate "dining room" but the pizza was the hit! You really can't go wrong with any of the many choices!
Made In New York Pizza
$
Closed
(53)
Advertisement
Photos
271 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10023
Made in New York Pizza is a renowned pizza shop in New York City, known for serving the best pizza in town. Their award-winning pizza is made from fresh, natural ingredients, high-quality cheeses, and the famous NYC water, resulting in a delicious and unique dough.
With locations in the Upper West Side and West Village, Made in New York Pizza offers a fun atmosphere where everyone is welcome. Whether dining in or ordering online, customers can expect a wide variety of flavors and toppings to choose from, ensuring a satisfying and enjoyable dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0(53)
Queenie N.
1/17/2026
We ordered a large pizza with barbeque chicken , black olives and onions. And it cost a total of 78. 52 and it wasn't worth it at all. By time the pizza got here at our location it wasn't hot at...
Yvette G.
5/31/2025
This pizzeria is always busy with neighborhood locals, passerbys & afterschool kids. It's clean, friendly & their very wide assortment of slices & pies are delicious, good sized & satisfying. The...
Lauren L.
5/6/2024
This slice hit fs. After having a series of mid pizzas, so glad to finally have one that really made me think "damn that's good". Ngl, it was kinda cold even though it was put in the pizza oven...
Dede F.
5/13/2024
I've never tasted a flavor of pizza this amazing before. Usually I'm not a big fan, but the crust was so thin on the pizza. Margarita and the tomato sauce was out of this world. The eggplant...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement