Island Thrift

$$$
Closed
yelp logo

(37)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

1800 Route 112
Medford, NY 11763

Island Thrift is a local thrift store situated in Medford, NY, offering a wide selection of secondhand items at affordable prices.

With a focus on sustainability and community support, Island Thrift provides a convenient shopping experience for those seeking unique and budget-friendly treasures.

Generated from their business information

Reviews

yelp logo
2.537 reviews
Photo of Jessica R.
Jessica R.
8/2/2024

I've passed this place while going out to tractor supply co and always wanted to go in. I finally went t with a friend this past weekend and it was great. The selection of items is great. I was...

Photo of Jamie L.
Jamie L.
12/2/2025

I'm an avid thrifter and probably been to every thrift store on LI. This thrift store by far the most expensive thrift store I've ever shopped in. Mens jeans average $20.99-24.99, I kid you not....

Photo of Tom F.
Tom F.
8/6/2024

Overpriced crap. You can get brand new items and clothing cheaper at Walmart. A lot of clothing that should be donations for free because no one would buy such lame clothing. Place sucks and...

Photo of Alphonse G.
Alphonse G.
1/8/2024

I've been stopping in here frequently, mainly looking for cast iron. I've found several pieces, some that I'd call vintage, others I'd call modern users. I've yet to figure a system to which...

Photo of Rafik C.
Rafik C.
6/5/2023

Firstly, Island Thrift is a great place to find bargains for used or donated items that are oftentimes new or gently used. That being said, there are some caveats one needs to be aware of before...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkMedfordIsland Thrift

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Advertisement