Terri H.
1/4/2026
Amazing cookies and cakes. The staff is so patient and sweet. drive from NJ for the best desserts
Holtermann's Bakery
$
Closed
(72)
Advertisement
Photos
405 Arthur Kill Rd
Staten Island, NY 10308
Holtermann's Bakery is a well-established bakery located on Staten Island, boasting an impressive 150-year history. Known for its variety of baked goods, it has become a local staple in the community. Despite its reputation, some customers feel that their expectations are not always met.
The bakery offers a range of products, but feedback indicates that not all visitors are satisfied with the quality. Recently, some patrons have experienced issues with order fulfillment, including delays for special occasions like Thanksgiving. Holtermann's Bakery continues to be recognized as a significant part of Staten Island's food scene.
Generated from the web
Reviews
4.0(72)
Leslie B.
1/3/2026
My last visit there was to pick up jelly donuts for Chanukah. They were far below my expectations in every way! Hardly any filling; very dry donut. If DD can put out a better donut than...
Anthony N.
12/21/2025
Never enough onion rolls...... All the bake goods are great. Going there over 45 years. They must be great....
Alma P.
4/20/2025
I just moved to SI and discovered this bakery. Everyone is friendly and everyone I go there, there is some new addition to their inventory. What I've had here so far is delicious. Very clean and...
Paul L.
5/11/2025
Huge selection, family owned team very helpful and everything is always delicious, Great prices, have to try the pickles
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement