Jessica L.
10/8/2025
So fun and great food! Their Greek salad is so big and yummy. I love their pumpkin beer too with the cinnamon rim.
Goody Two Shoes
$$
Closed
(37)
Advertisement
Photos
42 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Goody Two Shoes in Bay Shore, NY offers a unique experience on Main Street, providing a place to unwind and let loose after a day of being on your best behavior. With a thoughtfully crafted menu and a selection of craft cocktails, this establishment ensures that guests feel truly satisfied and indulged.
At Goody Two Shoes, patrons can enjoy a variety of delicious food options, including brunch and happy hour specials, while sipping on carefully curated drinks. Whether it's a rare bourbon, barrel-aged beer, or a perfectly mixed cocktail, guests are guaranteed to have a good time in this vibrant and lively atmosphere.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5(37)
Lily C.
3/24/2025
Love everything about Goody Two Shoes. The ambience, the service, the vibe, the food, the Happy Hour specials, the music. Yep, I'll be back and I may plan a girls night out here. So pretty...
Christina H.
2/5/2025
Food is ok. The wings are a bit larger than I normally like but the flavor was good. The ribs were on the drier side but flavor was also good. I did not love the flavor of the egg rolls but the...
Annabelle L.
6/20/2025
Came on an afternoon during Happy Hour with a friend. The weather was nice so we got to sit outside. The servers were quick and attentive. We got their $9 spritzes, some wings, and the birria egg...
Jessica B.
6/4/2024
Formerly known as T.J. Finelys, Goody Two Shoes has come a long way since its Irish pub days - which are still dearly missed. Their new and elevated menu is a big step up from their former late...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement