Colette G.
2/19/2023
Great spot to catch some good Greek food before a movie at pj cinemas. Warm, well lit charming luncheonette kind of feel. Menu is reasonable. Waitstaff is very nice and attentive. Only down side...
Gilshar Greek Cafe
$$
Closed
(125)
Advertisement
Photos
1072 RT-112
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Gilshar Greek Cafe, located in Port Jefferson Station, NY, is renowned for offering some of the best Greek food on Long Island. This cozy cafe specializes in homemade dishes, featuring delicious gyros and a welcoming indoor dining atmosphere.
With a focus on quality and authenticity, Gilshar Greek Cafe aims to provide a delightful culinary experience that celebrates Greek cuisine. Whether dining in or ordering online, patrons can expect a satisfying meal that reflects the rich flavors of Greece.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.0125 reviews
jeff s.
12/19/2025
Nice atmosphere and servers. Not fancy but comfortable. Ordered lamb kabob wrap with 2x salad. No alcohol available Salad was good sized and fresh. Dressing was sweeter than I'm used to but ok....
Katelyn S.
4/10/2025
overall I left feeling a bit underwhelmed. My mom ordered a classic Greek gyro and I went for the pita melt, plus we shared an appetizer of dolmas. The dolmas just didn't hit the mark--lacking...
Jessica F.
9/27/2025
I will never order from here again. If you do, be aware you might wait over an hour longer than you were supposed to and still not get your food. After giving them 40 minutes to make my two...
Renata A.
2/25/2025
My family and I love coming here. The food is always fresh and delicious. The ambiance is very crisp and clean and the owner is very welcoming. We are always greeted with a friendly smile and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement