Jack M.
11/22/2025
Came here for lunch and got French onion soup + pesto chicken sandwich. This is a combo we order at a lot of places around Buffalo and this was by far the best. Side of tater tots was super...
Forty Thieves
$$
Open
(222)
Advertisement
Photos
727 Elmwood Ave
Buffalo, NY 14222
Forty Thieves is a lively eatery located in the heart of Buffalo NY offering a unique blend of American cuisine with a twist. Known for its vibrant atmosphere the restaurant features a diverse menu that includes everything from hearty burgers to creative cocktails. With its welcoming ambiance and friendly staff Forty Thieves is the perfect spot for casual dining or a night out with friends.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5222 reviews
Sammy K.
8/10/2025
Stopped here while taking a small wing tour in Buffalo and the group was thrilled. We got the beef on weck wings and the 40 sauce. The Forty thieves sauce was AMAZING! I'd drink that by the...
Amy K.
10/26/2025
Small but cool place on Elmwood in Buffalo. I was impressed by the pretzel so that's definitely a must have if you stop in! The Reuben was also really good and piled high with corned beef. The...
Stephanie L.
12/1/2025
Low to mid tiered quality. Even though it's buffalo, it shouldn't be so far food, salty process, and all the things. My salad was good but the shrimp I could not eat even after I told the server...
Kristen K.
4/15/2025
Unfortunately they were down to one chef when we went, but that didn't impact our service much except that the menu was reduced to burgers, salads and soups. Got the PBJ burger and fries. The...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement