L J.
9/13/2025
Gorgeous place to go with family or date night. We were welcomed with a big genuine smile. Our waitress, Tracey, was phenomenal. Extremely friendly, quick and efficient. The food was out of this...
fatfish on The Water
$$$
Closed
(402)
Advertisement
Photos
28 Cottage Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Fatfish on The Water offers a distinct dining experience focused on quality meals and attentive service. Known for its seafood, the restaurant provides a limited menu that can vary based on the availability of the chef. Guests can enjoy an atmosphere suitable for special occasions, such as anniversaries and birthdays.
The establishment prides itself on delivering excellent food, even with a limited selection during certain times. Diners have noted the restaurant's ability to maintain high standards in both cuisine and service, making it a dependable choice for memorable meals. Fatfish on The Water aims to create an enjoyable environment for visitors celebrating life's milestones.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5(402)
Dallana U.
9/24/2025
I was hear over the weekend for my dads birthday and the service was amazing. The food was good as well, although some stood out more than others. The Saffron Mussels were a favorite! We had a...
Rod N.
9/10/2025
Portions are small and over priced. For example: I ordered for main course Tuna with Crab tempura cost $42 and only one tiny tempura crab leg the size of my child's pinkie finger. The side order...
Theresa S.
7/9/2025
Fat Fish is a perfect place by the water to enjoy a delicious lunch or dinner . The restaurant has a coastal vibe and low key atmosphere. There is plenty of seating both inside and out , there is...
Vivian R.
8/2/2025
It's alway nice to dining outside in the summer time. Live Music is always is a plus. Reservations are recommended plus additional time is needed for outdoor dining. Service is alway outstanding...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement