Travis J.
12/22/2025
First off: I find it very clever as part of the grocery store. The food was Delicious and came out fast. The server was great. And the potions were large. What more can you ask for. One...
Fairway Market of 74th Street
$$
Closed
(651)
Advertisement
Photos
2131 Broadway
New York, NY 10023
Since their humble beginnings as a corner fruit and vegetable stand on the Upper West Side, Fairway Market has been committed to bringing customers excellent value, a wide variety of products, and the freshest foods. Their first store opened in 1954 and grew to a small chain of stores across the New York tri-state area over the next 30 years. Customers love the emphasis on small-batch goods, specialty imports, and foodie finds all at a great value. Fairway Market treasures its relationships with customers, small vendors, and farmers, making it a great addition to the Wakefern cooperative.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5(651)
Sarah G.
9/27/2025
I've eaten here 2x now Both times just horrible, unfortunately The breakfast my eggs were watery Dinner my salmon was overcooked and the rice was lumpy and also overcooked from sitting in a pot...
David S.
12/24/2025
What happened ?? We used to live this cafe. Great food great service and now the food is awful and the service is awful. I feel like I was being punked. We went twice because we wanted to make...
Kelsey A.
8/13/2025
The staff was so nice and helpful when I went. A little unorthodox, but it's a sit down cafe upstairs in the fairway where they serve a full menu of food, pastries, and coffee.
Nathan N.
12/8/2025
Place has really slipped. Slow and confused service. Food was overcooked dry and cold like it had been sitting. Its a pass for me now sorry.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement