Eagle Deli

"Awesome spot for breakfast and lunch. Bagels and iced coffees are off the hook good! Delicious. Darren is a doll. Stock up - they freeze well. Funky and fun decor, clean, picnic tables outside..."

"Fun local ice cream shop on Shelter Island. Pretty sure there aren't many options to choose from (especially open after 8pm or so). There was a decent but quick-moving line and a little wait. The..."

"Sometimes, a truly great meal is about so much more than what lands on your plate. Sure, delicious food helps, but sometimes it's the chef's magic touch, a server's witty banter, or the setting..."