David John A.
12/17/2025
Love, love, love this place. So happy I have family in Staten Island so I can come here. Great cookies, wild assortment and still haven't found one that I don't like. They also have cookie jars...
Cookie Jar
$$
Closed
(218)
Advertisement
Photos
1226 Forest Ave
Staten Island, NY 10310
Cookie Jar, located in Staten Island, NY, is renowned for its exceptional cookies and a variety of sweet treats, including cookie trays, baskets, and gift options available for shipping nationwide. Offering items like cookie jars with playful designs, the establishment caters to both individual and corporate clients looking for deliciously memorable gifts.
With locations in Forest and New Dorp, Cookie Jar emphasizes quality and creativity in its products, featuring items such as custom logo cookies and branded baskets. Their commitment to delightful confections makes them a favorite destination for those seeking sweets to brighten any occasion.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5(218)
Kanea M.
9/23/2024
The glass display cases are at the perfect height for a child to admire and easily choose from. I love that you see them acually re-stocking an supplying the display cases so they are always full...
Leuwell W.
2/1/2025
Crack head prices, what I mean by that is I got 5 items for $9.75 in North Carolina one cup cake is 6 dollars, cookies are 4 to 5 dollars. Please keep this trend going. I love the variety as well....
Kathleen H.
10/20/2025
Delicious cookies as always and amazing and helpful staff. The music I the store was a joy too loud for customers.
Ifeoma U.
3/12/2025
So good and such a gem. Please never close. I hate that Yelp is making me write at least 85 characters because that's really all there is to it.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement