Christine H.
3/3/2025
I will die on my grave saying that Citarella is the best supermarket in the area. A few reasons why I believe this: 1. Variety For a smaller supermarket, they have just about everything you...
Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side
$$$
Closed
(148)
Advertisement
Photos
1313 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10021
East Siders know their good eats, and our regulars stop by to pick up prepared salads, sandwiches, even rotisserie chickens. Picnics in Central Park are only a few blocks away! Have a Sunday dinner roast wrapped to go by our full-service butchers, or oysters shucked by skilled fishmongers. Need a hand? We offer same day delivery service, convenient in the busy East Side traffic! And of course, don't forget our incredible fish counter, with our professional fishmongers and our world-class selection of seafood available fresh from Fulton Fish Market!
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5148 reviewsDan G.
1/4/2026
Prepared food is mediocre, some cakes are very good (berries, pineapple & marzipan, ricotta cake, walnut cake) but others are lousy, like the strawberry rhubarb (filling is mushy and crust is...
P B.
12/24/2025
Overpriced and extremely underwhelming. I bought a tart from here which smelled like old eggs.
Julie P.
12/29/2024
Citarella is an upper east side staple and for good reason. When needing gourmet items its a good spot. Consistently reliable quality, fresh seafood, their prepped meals are good, welcoming staff...
Judy T.
12/17/2025
Butcher counter continues to decline with no actual butchers. They also said they stopped selling London Broil. Every time I go in, the service is slower and less professional butchers.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement