Cider Mill Playhouse

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(70)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

[10 - 14] Nanticoke Ave
Endicott, NY 13760
In the early 1970s, Binghamton University professor and soon to be theater department chairman, Dr. John Bielenberg sought to expand the theater department's available venues to an off-campus site.Dr. Bielenberg and his colleagues found the Cider Mill. It had been in the Ciotoli family since the 1940s, and was a popular seasonal attraction for lovers of fresh apples, cider and donuts. The warehouse side of the Cider Mill was just what they were looking for.In 1991, when it became necessary for the University to give up the playhouse, it was restarted as an independent non-profit by Tom Kremer, Craig Saeger and Barbara Wolfe. They were supported over the years by dedicated Board Members, a super-hardworking group of staff members, the Ciotoli family and the devotion of the patrons, donors and volunteers.In all, the last 38 years have brought more than 270 dramas, comedies and musicals, and more than 5,000 performances to the Playhouse stage.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0

(70)

Photo of Joe T.
Joe T.
12/26/2025

Hadn't been since I moved away, so stopped in for fresh donuts. Only downside is not having a place to sit and enjoy them, but friendly service.

Patti V.
7/30/2025

The new owners are wonderful but the new donuts are terrible. Sure hope they can work to duplicate the original.

Annette C.
6/11/2025

Love the different options now and happy to have locally made products at reasonable prices! Donuts are delicious!

Photo of Jillian P.
Jillian P.
9/28/2021

Stopped by on a whim and ended up having a blast! We wanted to try their cider slushies, and made a quick pit stop en route home. The slushies were good, but there was so much more...

Susan W.
9/17/2024

Donuts are tasteless and way overpriced. I grew up in this area and we never came here. It was a fun get out the house with my friends otherwise I would pass. ($60.00 for a tie dyed hooded...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkEndicottCider Mill Playhouse

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement