Food

Castaways On The Lake

Closed

(297)

Call

Website

Photos

244 Lake Rd

Webster, NY 14580

+1 (585) 323-2943

http://www.castawaysonthelake.com

Enjoy the most spectacular views and gorgeous sunsets on Lake Ontario while dining outside. Cozy evenings and incredible specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining spot. Our two tiered lakside decks are the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in spring and summer. Our menu offers delicious creations that are sure to tempt all palettes. Treat yourself to local favorites such as cajun rubbed blackened prime rib or our fresh seafood sampler platters. Our chefs also offer many pasta, fish, seafood and chicken dishes that are sure to please. We also offer off premises catering and take-out for your convenience. Exceptional food and scenic views are why the Castaways has been a favorite dining spot since its opening in 1906. Enjoy outdoor dining under our heated patio deck. Comfortably spaced tables and plenty of free parking make this a favorite Lakeside dining spot.

Also at this address

Castaways On The Lake

Castaways

Reviews

2.5297 reviews

Tyler M.

7/5/2025

Decent little spot on the lake The fries came out seasoned and salted which is a huge plus. Food overall was average, but definitely on the pricier side. Coconut shrimp was the biggest miss: $17...

Read more on Yelp

Jaxs F.

7/6/2025

Great food. Great service and Great VIEWS. We always have a wonderful lunch here at Castaways. The staff is top notch. We had the Crab Cakes, the Lobster Roll and the Lobster Bisque. We enjoyed...

Read more on Yelp

Lauri A.

8/14/2025

The view here is really nice. The outdoor seating was great! Definitely a place for drink's. The food was okay. Service was standard for this area and time of day.

Read more on Yelp

Lisa C.

8/11/2025

Service!! The waitress was rude. She brought my soup entree out 20 minutes before my partners entree. So we didn't really eat together. The view is spectacular though

Read more on Yelp

Gordon V.

9/14/2024

Was looking forward to dinner at Castaways for a long time. Unfortunately it didn't meet my expectations. The server was abrupt, no eye contact, very curt. The menu selections were great as was...

Read more on Yelp

Owner verified

See a problem?

Eating places

Castaways On The Lake

Castaways On The Lake, located in Webster, NY, is a premier waterfront restaurant that has been delighting guests since 1906. Known for its stunning views of Lake Ontario and incredible sunsets, it offers outdoor dining experiences on its two-tiered lakeside decks, making it a popular summer destination in Western New York. The restaurant features a diverse menu that highlights local favorites like cajun rubbed blackened prime rib and fresh seafood sampler platters, alongside a variety of pasta, fish, and chicken dishes. With comfortable seating, exceptional food, and off-premises catering options, Castaways promises a memorable dining experience for all guests. Generated from the website

Caterers

Castaways

Castaways On The Lake is a beloved waterfront restaurant located in Webster, NY, offering a delightful dining experience with stunning views of Lake Ontario. Known for its fantastic outdoor seating, the restaurant features a diverse menu that highlights local favorites, including cajun rubbed blackened prime rib and fresh seafood, making it a top summer destination in Western New York. With a history dating back to 1906, Castaways prides itself on exceptional food and a relaxing ambiance, complemented by beautiful sunsets. The establishment also provides catering services for parties and events, ensuring a memorable experience for all guests. Generated from the website

Bayside of Webster

Bayside of Webster is a senior living community offering a range of care services for older adults in Webster, NY. With a focus on providing a comfortable and supportive environment, Bayside of Webster strives to meet the unique needs of each resident while promoting independence and well-being. Generated from their business information

United States›New York›Webster›Castaways On The Lake