Caffinated New Yorker

Closed
yelp logo

(11)

Call

Advertisement

Photos

523 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10304

Caffinated New Yorker is a cozy eatery located in Staten Island NY where coffee lovers and food enthusiasts unite. This charming spot offers a diverse menu featuring artisanal coffee fresh breakfast options and delicious lunch items all served in a welcoming atmosphere. With its vibrant decor and friendly staff it’s the perfect place to relax grab a bite or catch up with friends.

Generated from this place's information

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5

(11)

Photo of Eric C.
Eric C.
10/13/2025

Excellent place. I really hope they stick around. The cortado hit the spot and my wife and I loved the affogatos. Service was excellent. I love how spacious the vibe is. Go. It's worth it.

Photo of S G.
S G.
11/13/2025

Excepcional place! This place is so cozy and breathtaking inside! I had breakfast and a pastry and it was so good! So fresh and delicious! The best coffee latte! I can't wait to bring my friends!...

Photo of Amanda W.
Amanda W.
5/11/2025

Coffeee is good but the pastries are mid, my blueberrry scone is ehh, and the ham and cheese croissant was just ok. The service was nice and decor was good but I don't love it, its a big space and...

Gee M.
12/20/2025

Oh shoot, I thought I updated this review months ago!!! Update, one month after my initial review, my wife walked in and the owner personally apologized to her for my experience and comped her...

Photo of Hasti P.
Hasti P.
5/22/2025

Cozy little spot with quality coffee & variety of pastries. Definitely one of the nicest coffee shops on the island (although the neighborhood is not ideal) but I hope they thrive.

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkStaten IslandCaffinated New Yorker

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement