Brandon W.
12/14/2025
We celebrated the 25th Birthday of our youngest son who recently moved to Brooklyn. With hundreds of restaurants to choose from, we made the reservation at Cafe Carmellini. Instagram doesn't do...
Café Carmellini
$$$
Closed
(114)
Advertisement
Photos
250 5th Ave
New York, NY 10001
Café Carmellini is the signature restaurant of James Beard Award-winning chef Andrew Carmellini, showcasing a culinary experience that draws from his 30-year career. The restaurant offers a sophisticated blend of Italian and French cuisine, infused with a quintessential New York vibe.
Set in an original neoclassical landmark mansion beautifully reimagined by Martin Brudnizki, the venue exudes lush maximalist elegance. Chef Carmellini's remarkable menu is a testament to fine dining and thoughtful craftsmanship.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0114 reviews
Eric K.
11/10/2025
I had the pleasure to dine at this beautiful restaurant by Andrew Carmellini recently. Yes, this is going to be a splurge for most people but I think the experience is overall worth it. Everything...
Anne C.
11/24/2025
Really lovely ambience and vibes with high ceilings and dim lighting. The star of the night was actually the breadsticks with olive oil!! We asked for multiple refills of this and loved it. We...
Jim M.
9/24/2025
While in NYC for the week, my wife and I dined at Café Carmellini, and what a wonderful experience it was. I had booked a month in advance with high hopes, and it did not disappoint. We started...
Alexis S.
1/2/2026
Me and my partner came here for an early dinner seating on NYE, and the venue is quite beautiful with soaring ceilings, plush banquettes and impressive chandeliers. The service was excellent and...
See a problem?
In these collections
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement