Kristine A.
11/30/2025
This is the second location of Buttercooky that I've visited. The first was in Floral Park, they made my wedding cake. This location has a lot for parking which is great. I ordered the Oreo mousse...
Buttercooky Bakery
$$
Open
(238)
Advertisement
Photos
495 New York Ave
Huntington, NY 11743
For over 50 years Buttercooky Bakery has served Long Island residents fresh-baked cookies, pastries and cakes. Our flagship store has become a Floral Park fixture and our Manhasset store has been building a following for a decade and counting. At Buttercooky, our quality shows in every delicious bite. We use only the finest ingredients available to create our baked goods. Buttercooky Bakery offers a variety of traditional European confections, as well as a wide array of cookies, pastries, pies and cakes for all occasions. Buttercooky Bakery opened its doors September 1962 in Floral Park, NY. Since that day, we have made it our mission to supply the Long Island community with the highest quality and freshest baked goods. Living by our trademarked motto, "Baked with Butter, Makes It Better." From these humble beginnings, we have continued to grow and expand in our never-ending pursuit for excellence, and have gained a loyal following.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0(238)
Roy J.
11/9/2025
I was here to get a cake for a coworker and William was a very nice and helpful young man. He was a delight to work with. He actually suggested things to help me pick the right cake out. The store...
Sam E.
2/15/2025
I will fully admit, I walked in here wanting to hate because of its trendy hot chocolate. But overall it was actually quite good! Inside is very spacious and filled with treats and cakes galore;...
Crystal L.
3/18/2025
Everything is better with you ! I had buttercooky make my gender reveal cake and have spent some time with some friends enjoying delicious treats and laughing and talking About life, love and...
Kerri B.
12/28/2024
First, yes, they have their own parking lot in Huntington...score!!!! This is one of the reasons why I can go to Huntington on a yucky day and not worry if I'm dressed warm enough! Another plus,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement