Rachael D.
10/20/2025
Authentic NY-style pizza according to my husband (born and raised in New York)! We absolutely love it here. Our go-to order is cheese and pepperoni, plus the buffalo chicken rolls -- my personal...
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza
$
Open
(41)
Advertisement
Photos
444 Borden Rd
Buffalo, NY 14224
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is a popular pizzeria in Buffalo, NY known for its delicious New York-style pizzas and casual dining atmosphere.
With a menu featuring a variety of classic and specialty pizza options, Brooklyn's Finest Pizza caters to both locals and visitors looking for a satisfying slice of pizza in the heart of Buffalo.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.541 reviews
Lucy Y.
12/11/2025
We saw all the highly rated reviews here so we Postmated dinner. We were underwhelmed by all of the things we tried: Side of meatballs - 2 mass produced salisbury steak tasting, surely from a...
Brendan C.
11/1/2025
The quest for the Best NY style pizza in WNY is over. BROOKLYN'S FINEST is the winner. They beat Ferros (Josh Allen's pick and my own), also in West Seneca. Both feature the required thin crust,...
Eric D.
12/7/2024
Holy crap this place was great and I never knew they existed! The Jamaican patty was awesome and the pizza and garlic knots even better. The staff were so friendly and welcoming and had a passion...
John B.
7/27/2025
I heard that the pizza was pretty good, but when I got their the help was super rude. I just walked out. Find a different pizza place there are around 25K in the Buffalo area. The owner was so...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement