Dominic P.
11/16/2025
Stick to the basics. It's the best pizza in New York style old school delicious. Don't go exotic pasta or chicken on your pizza keep it old school authentic. Just as good as Joes on Carmines.
Best Pizza Of First
$
Closed
(167)
Advertisement
Photos
1038 1st Ave
New York, NY 10022
Best Pizza on 1st Avenue, located at 1038 1st Avenue in New York City, serves a diverse menu featuring both classic and innovative pizza options to satisfy any craving. With house favorites like the Neapolitan cheese pizza and specialty offerings like the Meat Lover's Pizza, diners can enjoy a variety of flavors and styles suitable for both casual takeout and family meals.
Beyond pizzas, the establishment also boasts a selection of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and wraps, ensuring there's something for every palate. With deals and a commitment to affordability, Best Pizza on 1st Avenue is a go-to destination for pizza lovers seeking quality meals without crazy fees.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5167 reviews
Donna U.
10/27/2024
Average pizza/sub place. I first tried the slice with penne on it but it was too overwhelmingly carby, no surprise. Have had a few hot sandwiches with chicken cutlet. They chop up the chicken on...
Amy W.
5/1/2024
I have always thought that it was funny that this pizza place is called the Best Pizza on First. It's weirdly humble and less aggressive than other NYC pizza places that declare themselves the...
Craig M.
4/16/2025
Very delicious authentic NYC pizza. I've been numerous times and they only had one off day. I'd still recommend.
Tim O.
7/1/2024
The name is amusing and this very well may be the best pizza on 1st avenue. The crust has a nice chewiness to it. Unfortunately, the guy behind the counter was rearranging slices in the display...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement