American Legends

$$$
Open
yelp logo

(19)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

1107 Central Park Ave
Scarsdale, NY 10583
+1 (914) 725-2225
http://amerlegends.com

American Legends in Scarsdale, NY, has been a trusted destination for sports card and memorabilia collectors since 1992, known for their reputation of fairness, integrity, and honesty. As former collectors themselves, they understand the sentimental value of parting with prized possessions and offer a seamless process for selling collections of baseball, basketball, football, hockey, and other sports memorabilia.

As an Upper Deck Certified Diamond Dealer, American Legends boasts an extensive inventory of unique sports cards and memorabilia, catering to both seasoned collectors and enthusiasts alike. From vintage baseball cards like the 1933 Goudey Lou Gehrig to iconic basketball rookie cards such as the 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan, their collection showcases a wide range of valuable and sought-after items for sports memorabilia aficionados.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.019 reviews
Photo of Joseph D.
Joseph D.
11/21/2025

Found this place online when I called The staff was very courteous. The owner Mark was very helpful definitely going back for all my sports cards needs. Thanks for helping out Joe DiRollo

Read more on Yelp
Jonathan G.
8/28/2025

They don't sell action figures anymore for some reason in the mid 2000's they were selling comic books and sports merchandise. Now it's just only sports.

Read more on Yelp
Bob W.
3/1/2025

Such a great store in a strip mall. Insane selection of cards in every era, sport, and genre. They carry everything for your hobby of collecting and trading cards. The service is great and they...

Read more on Yelp
Kimberly A.
8/28/2024

over charges customers by $300 for a hobby box . meanwhile they get a slight cheaper price for through Topps affiliate program. Card shops like them should be relegated by Topps. It's absurd and...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Noah S.
Noah S.
3/7/2023

Been here several times. Last time I asked if I can make an offer on a couple of cards. They literally laughed at the notion that someone would offer to buy something at something other than...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Alternate Universe
Comic books, Collectibles and antiques, mail order, Trading cards: baseball or other sports, entertainment, etc.

Alternate Universe

17
•
$$
"Nice selection of books here. Came her a few times a couple years back when I was looking for issues to fill runs. They were super friendly and helpful in person and on the phone. I ended up not..."
photo of David R.
Trading cards: baseball or other sports, entertainment, etc., Collectibles and antiques, mail order

Dugout Dreams

1
"Great selection, reasonable prices, and the owner was very friendly. Don't come into the store expecting retail prices, not going to happen. First time seeing a bunch of wax outside of ebay on..."
Galaxy Comics
Comic books, Stamps, coins, and other collectibles, mail order, Collectibles and antiques, mail order

Galaxy Comics

61
•
$$
"I was late to the Bitter Root fan club. [Context: Bitter Root is a comic book series, published by Image Comics, about a Black family who hunts monsters and attempts to cure them. It's set in the..."
photo of Brandon G.
United States›New York›Scarsdale›American Legends

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Advertisement