Key K.
10/28/2025
service was truly excellent! I really liked the greeting we received and our waitress! burgers juicy and made exactly like we ordered and the French fries are crispy - really really good! . French...
Amenia Steak House
$$
Open
(76)
Advertisement
Photos
4905 Route 44
Amenia, NY 12501
Amenia Steak House offers a range of lunch options and emphasizes quality food and service. The restaurant has faced challenges in maintaining its standards, with some past patrons expressing concerns about the overall experience. Despite previous issues, it remains a place where diners can explore lunch offerings in a casual setting.
Located in Amenia, the steakhouse aims to provide customers with a satisfying dining experience. While the establishment has faced criticism in the past, it continues to attract attention as a spot for lunch. Diners are encouraged to visit and discover what the restaurant has to offer.
Generated from the web
Reviews
3.576 reviews
Sophia C.
11/7/2025
The food and drinks are always fabulous! Ambience is rustic country charm, perfect for date night!
Claudine R.
11/5/2025
Wanted to have steak dinner while driving through this side of New York. Amenia Steakhouse popped on Yelp but didn't have menus nor significant reviews, but we decided to eat here anyway. We sat...
Diane C.
12/3/2025
The bar area is very noisy. Ordered my steak medium and it was chard on the outside and raw on the inside. Waitress never came back to check on our table. Very disappointed in the meal , the...
Ernie F.
6/18/2024
This was a great stop to make, as it was recommended by one of my family members. Parking isn't too bad for the most part, with plenty of spaces to be filled. We were seated upon entering and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement