Kelly L.
11/7/2025
Amazing customer service. The owners really care about their customers and take good care of every order!
Pizza Man
$$
Open
(136)
Advertisement
Photos
574 Newark Pompton Tpke Ste 5
Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Pizza Man is a casual, Italian restaurant that operates as a BYOB establishment. It focuses on providing a friendly atmosphere where customers can enjoy good food in a relaxed setting. The restaurant features a store front style, making it accessible for both dine-in and takeout options.
While Pizza Man is well-known for its pizza, it has recently seen patrons exploring other menu items as well. The restaurant aims to bring back the feel of old family-style dining, where good food and smiles create a welcoming experience. However, some customers have expressed a desire for improvements in the taste of the pizza offered.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5136 reviews
Christina D.
9/9/2025
Hooo boy, where to start. This is a very small pizza joint that also sells lots of homestyle Italian dishes but doesn't have a liquor license, so you have to BYOB (wine). My family has been...
Angela YJ B.
8/5/2024
Every time I am there, I always find either a stained wine glass (lipstick mark) or chipped plates, either the individual ones they provide or even on the served dishes. I just hope they would...
Michelle D.
11/8/2024
after not being here in over 40 years. They didn't disappoint. Just wow !!!!!!! Great service and AMAZING food ..... when in JERSEY. It's a MUST STOP Frankie
Sheila N.
6/9/2025
I think they changed owners but I decided to try anyway because their dishes used to be pretty good. The Shrimp Norman had way too much heavy parmesan cheese and garlic. It actually had a "sharp"...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement