Robert S.
12/8/2025
This eatery takes the stage in Poet's Square off the appropriately named Thoreau Road in Freehold Township. Brand: 5/5 Pies in Poet's is an Italian eatery in Poet's Square, which is a small,...
Pies in Poets
$
Closed
(6)
Advertisement
Photos
40 Thoreau Dr
Freehold, NJ 07728
Step into the world of Pies in Poet’s Pizzeria, an enchanting eatery nestled at 40 Thoreau Drive in Freehold, NJ. This charming establishment adds a poetic touch to every dish, promising a culinary adventure that delights the senses. As the sibling location to the esteemed Romeo's Pizza Manalapan, Pies in Poet's inherits a legacy of pizza mastery, blending classic techniques with innovative flair.
With a diverse menu that caters to all cravings, Pies in Poet's Pizzeria invites guests to savor a fusion of tradition and contemporary culinary artistry. Whether you're a connoisseur of fine pizzas or a curious newcomer, this pizzeria ensures a dining experience that lingers in your memory. Discover the magic of Pies in Poet's Pizzeria, where each bite is a verse in a gastronomic sonnet, waiting to be savored.
Generated using this place's available information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.56 reviewsEric S.
11/21/2025
As much as I hate to say this, the Philly Cheese Steak I purchased was horrible. It was supposed to come with "The Works" and yet, there was very little peppers, mushrooms, onions and cheese....
Andrew W.
6/21/2024
Fantastic slice. Thin, crispy and the tip doesn't flop over. Great cheese and not too heavy. Love this place.
Tom H.
11/3/2023
Ordered a takeout pepperoni pizza... it was mediocre at best. Crust was dry and they skimped on ingredients. I understand times are tough and they need to find margin where they can, but I think...
Brittany C.
11/8/2023
People in here are always friendly and prices are fair. Love the specialty slices and the dinners are great. Fast delivery. Have used them for hosting Halloween and also stopped in here many...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement