Mike M.
11/20/2025
Pie Girl is incredible. Every week they have new, interesting, and exciting flavors and I can't help but buy an entire frankenpie almost every time I visit. The Salted Honey Lavender, Lemon...
Pie Girl
$
Closed
(32)
Advertisement
Photos
117 W Ward St
Hightstown, NJ 08520
Pie Girl, located in Hightstown, NJ, has been delighting pie enthusiasts for eight years with its unique farm-fresh creations. The offerings include inventive flavors such as salted honey lavender, chocolate-covered strawberry, cranberry chess, and sweet Jersey corn custard.
Renowned for her homemade yet elevated pies, Chelsea Frosta has garnered praise from notable figures, including James Beard award semifinalist Matthew Rosenzweig. His favorites include the grapefruit chess pie, apple crumb pie, and rustic chocolate pie, which are available at his bakeshop in Shrewsbury, NJ.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.532 reviews
Laureen Y.
11/19/2025
My sis told me about this place. Went here with her on saturday morning. We got the brownie pie, honey almond apple pie, passionfruit cake, brownie, bacon quiche, and the emma sandwich. It was all...
Anna Q.
11/10/2025
The pizza here is so good!!! I'm def a savory girly so I love that they have other items other than sweets! The pies are so good and so fun that they change it up weekly!
Tony C.
12/2/2025
Amazing pies! We opted for the Franken-pie. A mix of types I selected, 1/4 pie each. There's other baked goods, but that's for the next visit.
Alivia D.
2/22/2025
Pie Girl knows what she's doing while whipping up her incredible pies. I love the whole concept of a weekly rotating menu, and it seems that each item is perfectly curated. The way to go is...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement