Joshua R.
11/15/2025
You hear "mustard pie" and if you're like me you think, "WHAT?!" I'm telling you fam, go get one. We got one with garlic and sausage, and Mama Mia (or Papa Pia?) it was a home run. Service was...
Papa's Tomato Pies
$$
Closed
(473)
Advertisement
Photos
19 Robbinsville Allentown Rd
Trenton, NJ 08691
Papa's Tomato Pies, established in 1912, is recognized as the oldest continuously family-owned pizza restaurant in the United States, located in Trenton, NJ. Known for their unique Mustard Pie—a local delicacy featuring a thin layer of spicy brown mustard beneath the cheese and topped with tomato—the restaurant boasts a rich history and a diverse menu that pays homage to traditional Italian cuisine.
The menu at Papa's includes a variety of tomato pies, appetizers, pastas, salads, and desserts, all prepared with the quality and care that has sustained their family legacy for over a century. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, the restaurant offers takeout and delivery options, ensuring that their iconic dishes can be enjoyed by all.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0473 reviews
Zach V.
10/10/2025
The hype is real.. I won't sugar coat it. Papa's Tomato pie is one of the best pie's around. Trenton style is my favorite as I grew up in Ewing, NJ until I was 7 and my relatives still live in...
Rich W.
9/16/2025
Papa's and nearby DeLorenzo's both serve very good tomato pies, but Papa's are honestly just a little more to my liking than DeLorenzo's pies. To me, the sauce at Papa's stands out a little more,...
Chris E.
7/24/2025
Another check on our pizza pilgrimage checklist and JUST AS GOOD AS ADVERTISED. Papa's is located at a small, quiet strip mall and we arrived on the day after July 4th at around 1PM. Even though...
Dolly C.
7/5/2025
- Thin, crispy pizza with tons of sauce. Good flavor, but a bit too crunchy. - Soft drinks aren't watered down but come full of ice and no free refills. - Toddler friendly with plenty of high...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement